Why do people love SUVs and trucks so much?

SUVs and pickup trucks seem like peak overconsumption to me. Why would anyone drive a massive gas-guzzling vehicle to an office job when they could take a small, fuel-efficient car? I get that farmers or people with specific needs might require these vehicles, but for most people, they seem unnecessary.

I’ve always disliked them, but after reading this Vox article (Large SUVs are popular, but they kill pedestrians and people in smaller cars), it feels like we need more organizations pushing back against these oversized vehicles. Does anyone know of groups working on this? Any suggestions would be appreciated.

As a small car driver, it’s getting so hard to find actual small cars anymore. Most of what they call ‘small’ now are just tiny SUVs. I grew up with sedans, and we managed just fine as a family. Now, people look down on small cars. I even have friends who refuse to ride in mine. I don’t get the hate. It’s easier to park, and I spend way less on gas.

@Teagan
Even midsize pickups are massive now. A Ford Ranger today is the size of an F-150 from years ago, and F-150s are the size of older F-350s. When I visited Australia, I was amazed at the variety of truck sizes. They seem to have way more sensible options. I blame the Chicken Tax for messing up the U.S. market.

@Bliss
The Chicken Tax definitely contributed, but it’s also about CAFE standards. They allow manufacturers to average out fuel efficiency across their lineup, which incentivizes them to make bigger vehicles. It’s easier to hit fuel efficiency goals when your whole lineup is massive.

@Teagan
I’ve been driving the same small car for 14 years. It’s not great for snow, but if I absolutely need to get out, I’ll Uber or find another way. I once had to Uber to an emergency vet in a snowstorm and gave the driver a huge tip.

@Teagan
Fellow small car driver here. It’s not hate—it’s insecurity. Some guys think their masculinity is tied to the size of their truck, and they project that onto others. Ignore them. It’s pathetic.

@Teagan
It’s impossible to find a sedan now. Everything is an SUV or crossover.

@Teagan
What kind of person refuses to ride in their friend’s car? That’s just rude.

@Teagan
Sometimes it’s about practicality. I camp monthly and need something that can tow a small camper. A sedan just can’t do that. Also, sedans aren’t great for carrying more than four people unless they’re small kids. We once crammed five adults into a sedan for a 45-minute trip, and it was miserable.

I have two kids and recently switched to a hybrid minivan. It gets the same fuel efficiency as my old car but is so much more convenient for car seats and strollers. I think the key is finding the right vehicle for your needs and keeping it for a long time.

@Arden
Minivans are so underrated. They’re versatile—you can fit people, cargo, or both depending on how you arrange the seats.

Lael said:
@Arden
Minivans are so underrated. They’re versatile—you can fit people, cargo, or both depending on how you arrange the seats.

The newer hybrid minivans are especially great. They get way better gas mileage than older models—some start at 30 mpg.

Lael said:
@Arden
Minivans are so underrated. They’re versatile—you can fit people, cargo, or both depending on how you arrange the seats.

This thread has convinced me. When I need to replace my current car, I’m looking at minivans. Station wagons aren’t coming back anytime soon.

Lael said:
@Arden
Minivans are so underrated. They’re versatile—you can fit people, cargo, or both depending on how you arrange the seats.

Minivans without the seats have more cargo space than most trucks. You can even fit a 4x8 sheet of plywood in them.

@Arden
Minivans are definitely better than huge pickups. The sloped front improves visibility, so they’re safer for pedestrians.

@Arden
What hybrid minivan did you get? We’re also looking for one for our kids.

Niko said:
@Arden
What hybrid minivan did you get? We’re also looking for one for our kids.

We went with the Toyota Sienna. It’s great, especially with the all-wheel drive option.

Arden said:

Niko said:
@Arden
What hybrid minivan did you get? We’re also looking for one for our kids.

We went with the Toyota Sienna. It’s great, especially with the all-wheel drive option.

Our family’s first minivan was a Sienna too! It lasted us 16 years and so many road trips before a truck totaled it. I miss that car every day.

@Arden
It took me a while to come around, but now I see the value in vehicles like the Honda CR-V. I used to think I’d always want a tiny car, but as life changes, so do your needs.

Fuel economy regulations have killed the small truck market in the U.S. Manufacturers are incentivized to make full-sized pickups instead. I have a GMC half-ton, but I’d have bought a smaller truck like a Toyota if they were still available.